Leopard Opinion: Why Apple won't rewrite the Finder

I write this with a heavy-ish heart because there is nothing I would like better for Apple to do than to have a totally bulletproof (rewritten or not) Finder in Leopard. Unfortunately, I have to admit that the chances seem to be slim. I don't think Apple is going to go beyond fixing bugs and making the usual incremental changes. Why?

Well, I always feel like I need to see everything from the perspective of an unbiased, average Mac user, and believe me, of all the complaints I have ever heard about Macs from normal people, none of them have been about the Finder. It's not a Finder I'm satisfied with (oh, I just need the tiniest reason to start Finder-bashing) but it works.

If you're not using network volumes or any kind of misbehaving volumes (failing hard drives or optical discs), you probably haven't experienced very many Finder crashes. Annoyances perhaps, but not many outright crashes. And perhaps a large number of people don't use network volumes. But Apple knows that a lot of people use networks now - oh, what a revelation! - and I expect Leopard to fix network-related Finder issues. Although not completely alleviated, I can see that some work has already been put into the Finder's network-related features. The Leopard update to Finder is probably going to make the current paradigm work without bugs and not radically change anything.

Another area where I expect the Finder to change is the Little Things™. The current builds of Leopard already show that Apple has addressed some huge usability issues related to views in the Finder. Grid Spacing is now an option as a lot of people find that the default spacing, although elegant, is much too spacious for smaller screens. Also, the stupidity of the View Options inspector being applicable to "All Windows" by default has been corrected and a much, much more common-sensicle "Use as Defaults" button has replaced that most annoying of radio buttons.

Another similar tweak is the fact that pressing Return to rename a file will now only highlight the part of the filename before the extension. And as you can see by the first screenshot right at the top, the Finder will also have alternating blue and white horizontal lines in the List view. Yeah, so basically, expect these but no real big stuff.

The true spatial Finder which I would prefer to this one is probably a dream that I should stop dreaming. It isn't going to happen. It's not a priority. A bunch of maybe… twenty… geeks want it which simply isn't enough to justify the work; also because most people seem to be perfectly okay with the current state of the Finder. On the bright side, the Dock's going to have spring-loaded folders, so hurray! 

Comments (11) Posted on at  

  • » You should definitely check out Path Finder, I'd been having all sorts of annoyances witht he Finder myself, and when I found such a great solution, I never looked back.

    You can check it out at http://www.cocoatech.com/
  • » "The true spatial Finder which I would prefer to this one is probably a dream that I should stop dreaming. It isn't going to happen. It's not a priority. A bunch of maybe… twenty… geeks want it which simply isn't enough to justify the work"

    More like twenty thousand geeks want a true spatial Finder.

    Of course, that's still not nearly enough to make it happen.

    The only way to make this happen is to kidnap Steve-o, and not release him until he sees the light.

    I don't miss much from OS 9, but I really do miss the spatiality.
  • » Maybe we'll see a brand new Finder in Mac OS XI...
  • » The sad thing is, the Finder IS spatial - if only windows wouldn't sometimes show up "brushed/browser" mode. I've noticed that the Finder saves a different state depending on whether or not the window was opened by the Finder or by another program (AppleScript, "open" command). Once I open a folder both ways and set it to "not-brushed", I never see it again. And none of my "spatial" features are affected.

    So in a nutshell, the Finder IS spatial and has been for a while, except for the unfortunate tendency to open windows in browser/brushed metal mode.
  • » The problem with the spatiality in the current Finder is that there is no easy option that I can set that says: "Please do not use the brushed metal view; please use the simplified spatial view for all new Finder windows." And until that feature is available, I'm not going to be satisfied.

    Plus, a more perfect solution would be to have spatiality while still maintain the sidebar and toolbar. This can be partially accomplished currently by setting new folders to open in new Finder windows.
  • » I have given up on a new Finder too, but I don't think the current one is beyond repair, its got better and better with every release, its just every release gave us new features and left the fundamental problems.

    Finger crossed boy and girls, I have a good feeling about this one, Apples engineers get pissed of with watching the rainbow cursor too.
  • » I wish that they would build in the same functionality as Windows. I use XP at work, Mac at home and it is totally frustrating on the Mac having to go back to the Finder every time I want to rename, move or delete a file.

    For example in Adobe programs (under XP) in the Open, Save, or any of those dialogue boxes, I can rename, delete, create new folders, cut and paste folders..I can even FTP and zip!! It is so efficient when working on several jobs throughout the day.

    Does anyone know why Mac does not have this functionality? And why does no one talk about this? It's baffling to me. Maybe I am missing something. I am still on 10.1 as I have been waiting for this functionality.
  • » >>The only way to make this happen is to kidnap Steve-o, and not release him until he sees the light.

    Well, I mean... there is another option... You could try, maybe, WRITING ONE YOURSELF.

    Dude wrote pathfinder. What's to stop you writing your own finder replacement?
  • » Oes Tsetnoc one of the ways in which we can learn seo besides Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa. By participating in the Oes Tsetnoc or Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa we can improve our seo skills. To find more information about Oest Tsetnoc please visit my Oes Tsetnoc pages. And to find more information about Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa please visit my Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa page and other update like as Beratnya Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa, Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa di perpanjang and Jangan Berhenti Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa. Thank you So much.

    Oes Tsetnoc | Lanjutkan Mengembalikan Jati Diri Bangsa
  • » Stop wasting your time with part time job and go to http://www.taxvacancies.com Sign up today and find the best paying summer job and apply for places online. Find your next dream job and get out of your current job that is taking you nowhere in life. Find the best part time job vacancies when you sign up and search today!
  • » Let me start by saying nice post. Im not sure if it has been talked about, but when using Chrome I can never get the entire site to load without refreshing many times. Could just be my computer. Thanks. Replica Watches

CrossOver Beta 3

CrossOver Beta 3 is out and it can be grabbed here. Still quite useless, I'm afraid.



Posted on at  

iTunes 7.0.2 brings "iTunes" keyboard shortcut back!

This is really happy news for people (like me!) who were horribly used to summoning iTunes' main window by pressing Apple-1. Well, now it's back and it's Apple-Option-1! Deep inside, I knew they'd have to bring it back eventually. And yeah, Apple-Option-2 is the rejuvenated form of Apple-2.



Posted on at